Gone West

Dreaming of a Better Life in America

Was it too good to be true? An enormous continent, open for settlement, with countless opportunities to get rich quick. A new world full of possibilities for a better life, where the family’s future could be secured. 

The migration stream from Norway to America is considered to have begun in 1825. Between then and 1930, almost 900,000 Norwegians followed the dream of a better life “over there.” 

Most of these Norwegians settled in the frontier regions of the Midwest, where land could be purchased cheaply. The reality they were met with there was often a far cry from what they had been dreaming of. Along with the plentiful land, deadly epidemics, extreme weather, bandits, and violent conflicts were also, unfortunately, plentiful. 

What did Norwegian immigrants really dream of – a livelihood, cheap land, freedom, gold? What, exactly, was the reality like that they encountered on the frontier? How did they do there? And who would suffer because of what these Norwegians were dreaming of?

0.1 The Great Dream 

Everything was bigger in America – and not just the trees, crops, and lush prairies. Hundreds of thousands of Norwegians were enticed by the many great opportunities, and the liberal government which allowed people to do virtually as they pleased. America was a land of entrepreneurs – of dreamers. 

However, this image of America as the place where everything was larger than life did not always reflect reality. This was captured by photographer Haakon Bjornaas, the son of Norwegian American farmers. Bjørnaas used surrealism and humour in his photo montages, placing farmers alongside super-sized crops. 

0.1 Photographer: Haakon Bjornaas. “Scene from a farm near Underwood, Minnesota”. Northwest Minnesota Historical Center, Moorhead, 1909. 

1.

Dreaming of Land

Norway experienced explosive population growth in the nineteenth century. Increasingly, families had more children who survived into adulthood. Though the practice of primogeniture ensured a future for the oldest son on the farm, what would happen to the other children? 

In the western territories of America, more and more land was being made available for settlement by European immigrants. Native Americans were being removed ever westwards. European immigrants filled the role as settlers in the expansion of the “Empire of Liberty.” 

This affordable land, which after a while became completely free through the Homestead Act of 1862, was what drew Norwegians out into the “Wild West”. Here, they could bring with them their traditional peasant lifestyle and realise the dream of upwards mobility, either rising from the working classes or conserving their position as independent landholders, thus contributing in different ways to the building of the American nation. 

1.1 “America for Dummies”  

“In what general direction from Norway does America lie, and how far is it away?” How do you get there? Had the country been ruined by a plague? Were the farms empty and ready for them to move into? Were those who crossed the sea captured by pirates and sold into slavery? In Norway, the questions about America were many and the answers few. 

To help inform his ignorant countrymen, many of whom were willing to emigrate, Ole Rynning, the son of a pastor and himself a schoolteacher who had emigrated in 1837, wrote a Q&A about America. Using simple questions like those above, Rynning gave Norwegian readers a quick introduction to life in America. 

As a direct result of the publication of Rynning’s manual, two shiploads of migrants left Norway the following year. By that time, Rynning was already dead and the settlement where he had lived had collapsed. The area turned out to have been a swamp filled with malaria.  

1.1 Ole Rynning: Sandfærdig Beretning om Amerika, til Oplysning og Nytte for Bonde og Menigmand. Christiania: Guldberg og Dzwonkowski, 1839.

1.2 The Letter Which Caused the Emigration  

In the first decade of Norwegian migration to the US, from 1825 to 1835, only a handful of people made the journey and settled in upstate New York. In 1835, one of these migrants returned to Norway, bringing with him various letters which quickly attracted attention and influenced many other Norwegians to emigrate. 

Those letters by the emigrant Gjert Gregoriussen Hovland turned out to be especially influential. They were widely distributed in Norway and pushed many to emigrate. In his letters, Hovland writes about “a massive amount of land” in a place called “Ellenaaes” – Illinois. 

The transcript shown here is one of Hovland’s letters. It had been sent to relatives in Kinsarvik, and the local priest forwarded this copy to the Norwegian authorities. The sudden and great wave of migration had become a case for concern. 

1.2 Gjert Gregoriussen Hovland, letter to Torjuls Asbjeldsen Mæland, Ullensvang diocese, Kinsarvik parish, dates 22 April 1835. Transcript as attachment to report to the Ministry of Finance from parish priest Herzberg. Owner: The National Archives of Norway.

1.3-1.4 Who Owns the Land?

The United States of America was established in 1776, when several colonies on the eastern seaboard of North America declared independence and broke free from the British Empire. That became the start of a long period of overland westward conquest. Through wars and treaties and, not least, the removal of the North American Native populations, the US gradually turned into the 50 states we have today. 

In Illinois, the warrior Black Hawk refused to give up his ancestral lands. He explained it thus:  

“I considered, as myself and band had no agency in selling our country – and that as provision had been made in the treaty, for us all to remain on it as long as it belonged to the United States, that we could not be forced away. I refused, therefore, to quit my village. It was here, that I was born – and here lie the bones of many friends and relations. For this spot I felt a sacred reverence, and never could consent to leave it, without being forced therefrom.” 

Black Hawk’s uprising was quelled in 1832. In this autobiography, which was dictated, translated, and published shortly thereafter, Black Hawk presented his own and other Native Americans’ perspectives on the colonisation of the Midwest. 

The news about the Native Americans having been pacified in Illinois led directly to the establishment of the first Norwegian settlement in the interior. The settlement along the Fox River in Illinois would become the mother settlement for the great wave of immigrants who in Norway had heard the rumours of cheap land in the Midwest. 

1.3 Black Hawk, Donald Jackson (ed.): Black Hawk. An Autobiography. Illinois: University of Illinois Press, 1990, printed by J. B. Patterson (ed.): Life of Ma-Ka-Tai-Me-She-Kia-Kiak or Black Hawk. Boston: Russell, Odiorne and Metcalf, 1834. 

1.4 Alfred M. Hoffy (ill.): Ma-Ka-Tai-Me-She-Kia-Kiah (Black Hawk), printed in History of the Indian Tribes of North America by Thomas L. McKenney (ed.) and James Hall (author). F.W. Greenough, c. 1838. Owner: Library of Congress.  

1.5-1.7 Hero or Villain?

To the Native Americans, pioneers like Guri must have appeared as anything but the heroic figures that other settlers made them out to be. But in settler communities, the story of the brave Norwegian woman who dramatically escaped the Dakota Uprising quickly turned to legend. The story was popularised among Anglo-Americans and as well as among school children in Norway. The narrative was a good fit for the already-popular Western genre of literature which mythologised and glorified the colonisation of the Midwest. In these stories, the settlers were the victims and resistance heroes. Their brave fight against nature and violent indigenous people helped legitimate the great territorial conquest – they had, after all, fought for their country. 

1.5 Johan Hambro (ed.): “Rødhudene ved Norway Lake” in Nordmanns-Forbundets julehefte. Oslo, Grøndahl & Søn, 1962. 

1.6 Nordahl Rolfsen: Lesebok for folkeskolen. Byutgave IV. Kristiania: Jacob Dybwads forlag, 1922. (Two copies.)

1.7 Frey W. (Wilhelm): Høvdingens Skat. Kristiania: Sophus Kriedts Forlag, 1890.

1.8 Violence on the Frontier

From Illinois, Norwegian immigrants continued moving further west. A treaty made between the government and several tribes in 1851 made Minnesota available for settlement. As compensation, the Dakota people would receive yearly payments and reservations, but the annuities never materialised. In 1862, the Dakotas rebelled. 

Norwegian immigrant Guri Olsdatter Endresen Rosseland was at the front line. Together with her husband Lars, Guri had settled in Minnesota in 1857. In the letter which Guri later wrote home to Norway, she tells the story of how she witnessed her husband and two sons being shot. She, however, managed to escape together with some of her children. Guri also saved the lives of several other settlers. Read the letter here.  

1.8 Portrait of Guri Olsdatter Rosseland in Illustrated History of Kandiyohi County, Minnesota by Victor E. Lawson and J. Emil Nelson (eds.). Willmar: Pioneer Press, 1905.

1.9 Transcription of letter

From Guri Olsdatter Rosseland to mother and other family members in Norway, 2 December 1866, from the published version in the newspaper Minneapolis Tidende, 9 February 1933.  

Harrison P. 0., Monongalia County, Minnesota, 2. desember 1866.  

Dear daughter, and your husband and children, and dearly beloved mother,  

I have received your letter of 14 April, and I send you herewith my heartiest thanks for it. It gives me great comfort and joy to know that you are all of good health and keeping well. I must also report briefly of my own circumstances and ask forgiveness from all of you that I have hesitated to write you of my dire fate. For a long time I was not myself, it affected my memory, courage and strength, whilst I was also reluctant to share such a sad bit of news with you, and I let it cool down for some time.  

During the time when the savages raged so fearfully here, I was not able to believe anything else than that my whole family would be murdered on the spot. But praise and thanks to God. My four daughters and I came through unscathed, with the exception of grief and need. Guri and Britta were tossed up on horseback and abducted by the Indians, but they managed to make their escape from the terrifying, rapacious lust they would have had to experience from these brutal, wild human beings, and since murdered. Praise be to God for protection. They managed to escape, came to some Americans, and were brought to safety.  

I myself wandered around with my little baby, after I had been in hiding and witnessed them shooting Lars and both boys. Our son Ola was shot through his shoulder, but recovered, though I left him also for dead. He recovered completely, but since died of natural illness, “pneumonia”. I had to leave Lars and my oldest son Endre died, and I had to flee. Between hope and fear, I wandered around with little Anna, six months old, in my arms. Almost crazy, I found my son Ole wounded along with two others, and to witness these killed and wounded was almost too much for a poor woman. But thanks be to God, I kept my life and my sanity. All I had was stolen and taken away, but what of that had I only had my beloved husband and son Endre, both of whom lie exactly where they fell? But what shall I say? God allowed it, and I must be thankful to God that I and my other children were saved.  

I must also let you know that my daughter Gertrud and her husband have land, which they received from the government for $16, in this country’s language known as a Homestead. When they have lived on the land for five years, they will receive a deed and complete possession of the land. They can sell it if they like or keep it if they like. They live about 24 English miles from here. My daughter Guri is away as a house servant for an American a hundred miles from here; she has been with the same people for four years. She is of good health and keeping well. I visited her recently, not knowing whether she was alive or dead. My two youngest daughters, Britta and Anna, are at home with me and doing very well. 

I must also remark that on 21 August, it was four years since I had to escape from my dear home and my dear daughters. I have still not been back there since, to the place where I once had a dear home and my wonderful family with me. An awful sight, all in ruins, and the memories of what those terrible Indians did. Many families have now moved back, so we hope to be able to see a pleasant home again someday. I am now in Sjur Endresen’s home a couple of miles from home.  

I must also tell you what I had before this sorrowful incident. I had 17 cattle, eight sheep and eight large pigs, along with many chickens. Now, I have again acquired six cattle, four sheep and one pig. I heard that our cattle had survived the autumn and winter on the hay we had set up and the stacks of wheat that remained unthreshed. Still, everything disappeared. The government gave me some compensation for the cattle and other farm animals. Of the six cows I now have, three are dairy cows. I have churned 130 pounds of butter, which made me $66. Someone advised me to sell my land, but I do not want to. Despite all the unpleasantness, it is a valuable memory of my dear husband and the nice time we shared here, and in hope that some of my own could take it over, and if you, my dear daughter, and your husband would like to come here, you could take it over.  

And now in closing, I will send my most heartfelt greeting to my dear, unforgettable mother, and you, my daughter, and your husband and children, and to all our relatives and friends. May the good God in His mercy soften our hearts so that we one day with songs of rejoicing can gather together with God and all the saints in the heavenly dwellings and see God face to face, for all eternity, where there is no more divorce, no sorrow, no death and no more darkness, for God on the throne will be our light.  

Your devoted, 

Guri Olsdatter.  

(Write back soon.)  

1.9 Transcription of letter from Guri Olsdatter Rosseland to mother and other family members in Norway, 2 December 1866, from the published version in the newspaper Minneapolis Tidende, 9 February 1933.  

1.10 The Midwest: Norwegian America

This map shows Norwegian settlements in America at the turn of the twentieth century, following approximately 75 years of huge waves of migration from Norway. Second only to Ireland, Norway was the country in Europe which experienced the highest level of emigration relative to its population. The Norwegian colonies made up a nearly continuous string of settlement upwards from Illinois to the northwestern part of the Midwest of the United States. In due time, the settlements also spread across the Canadian border. The main attraction prompting Norwegians to migrate was the cheap, accessible land. As a result, Norwegians became the most rurally oriented immigrant group within the whole of the United States. 

1.10 Martin Ulvestad’s “Kart over De Forenede Stater” og “Norge i Amerika”, from Martin Ulvestad: Norge i Amerika med Kart. Minneapolis, Minnesota: Norge i Amerika Publishing, 1901. 

1.11 The Settlement of Minnesota and the Dakota Uprising 

This map shows the earliest White settlement in the area where the Dakota Uprising took place in 1862. The number of Scandinavian settlers is significant, as shown by the names on the map. Straight north of Solomon Lake was the home of Guri and Lars Endresen Rosseland. The settlers who were killed in the 1862 conflict are marked with crosses. After the uprising, the Dakota were outlawed in Minnesota and forced westwards to reservations within what is today the states of North and South Dakota. 

1.11 Map section in Illustrated History of Kandiyohi County, Minnesota by Victor E. Lawson and J. Emil Nelson (eds.). Willmar: Pioneer Press, 1905.

1.12 Establishing the Dakota Reservation

This map shows the Great Sioux Reservation. The Sioux people included the Dakota. The reservation, which was established in 1868, was originally greater than what is shown on this map from 1882. The explanation for this is found in the American eagerness for gold. 

In 1874, an expedition led by George Armstrong Custer discovered gold in the Black Hills, the western area of the reservation. The ensuing gold rush led to yet another war with Native Americans. Black Hills was conquered and separated from the reservation. Both Custer, the gold miners, and the settlers broke the earlier treaty, which forbade Whites from trespassing on the reservation.  

1.12 General Land Office: “Territory of Dakota”. New York: Julius & Bien Co., 1882. Owner: David Rumsey Map Collection.

1.13 Partitioning the Dakota Reservation 

As this 1892 map shows, the Great Sioux Reservation was partitioned yet again when the territory of which it was part was split to make up the new states of North and South Dakota. This partitioning was made possible by the Dawes Act of 1887, which required that Native Americans were now to own land on an individual basis and not as tribes. Consequently, a certain size of land was offered to each household. The surplus was to be sold to settlers. 

Driven by the Homestead Act of 1862, Norwegian immigrants made their way to the Dakotas, which in time became two of the most Norwegian states of the US. In 1900, 23 per cent of the population of North Dakota were Norwegians, as were 12 per cent of the population of South Dakota. Today, slightly under a third of the population of North Dakota claims to be primarily of Norwegian descent. 

1.13 Office of Indian Affairs, Thomas Jefferson Morgan: “Map showing Indian Reservations within the Limits of the United States” (section). Washington D.C.: 1892. Owner: Library of Congress.

1.14 Little “House” on the Prairie 

The Act, which gave free land to everyone, including immigrants, stipulated that settlers had to “improve” their property and to demonstrate evidence thereof in order to be entitled to their claim. The idea had always been to encourage people to remain as independent farmers. 

The idea of “improvement” was rather vague. Many claimants built houses that were little more than shanties, only to sell their property with profit after the required five-year period of settlement. 

1.14 Foto: Ole Sigbjørnsen Leeland. “Oh gee, this is a Lonesome Town! Unexpected Visitor on the Claim”. Leeland Art Co., 1900–1910.

1.15 Revival on the Reservation 

In the 1890s, the Native American population had sunk to about 200,000, from several tens of millions before the arrival of the Europeans. This film shows the “Ghost Dance” which in the final decades of the nineteenth century spread as a millenarian revival across the Native American communities. The Dance was supposed to resurrect dead ancestors and endangered herds of bison as well as inaugurating peace among the Whites and the Natives. 

The millenarian movement was misunderstood by the American authorities and interpreted as militaristic and violent, giving government officials a reason to break up the traditional bonds of leadership within Native American tribes. At the Sioux Reservation, chief Sitting Bull was killed in 1890, while nearly 300 men, women, and children were massacred by the nearby creek of Wounded Knee. 

Several of those who had been dancing the Ghost Dance later took jobs in the Wild West show run by marksman and circus director Buffalo Bill. In the show, the Ghost Dance was demonstrated and used as entertainment, as shown in this film from 1894. The stories told by the dancers themselves were also recorded and now form an important contribution to our understanding of the peaceful nature of the Ghost Dance movement. They are also important for documenting the history of the Native Americans. 

1.15 “Sioux Ghost Dance”, performed by dancers from Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show in the studio of Thomas A. Edison in New Jersey, 1894. Owner: Library of Congress.

2.

Dreaming of Freedom

The very essence of the American Dream in a single word, the battle cry of the American republic was liberty – a liberty so great for those to whom it applied that it even enabled them to enslave others. In New York, the Statue of Liberty, dressed as she likely was in Norwegian copper from mines of Karmøy, welcomed Norwegian immigrants to the land of freedom. 

Long before the Statue of Liberty was built, the author of the Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson, had envisaged the future of the United States as an “Empire of Liberty”, a nation of yeoman farmers settling the entire North American continent. Such dreams resonated well with Norwegian immigrants. 

In America, everyone could have their own land and make a living. There were no restrictions on religion, women were freer, everyone could speak their mind, and even ordinary folks could participate in politics. But the immigrants brought with them more than just their household goods when they arrived. The prairie wagons also pushed Norwegian religion and culture onto the Western frontier, and wherever they settled, churches also appeared. 

2.3 On the Way to the Wild West 

The emigration, and specifically to Texas, helped Elise Tvede, a priest’s daughter, to find her way to enter the public sphere in Norway. Though few Norwegians ever went to Texas, a Norwegian newspaper editor, Johan Reinert Reiersen, had explored first-hand the various opportunities for Norwegian settlement in North America – and Texas, then an independent state, was his choice. In this manual, Pathfinder for Norwegian Emigrants to the United States of North America and Texas, Reiersen encouraged everyone to settle in this state. 

Elise Tvede was among those who followed Reiersen to Texas. But before she left, she had already become Norway’s first female newspaper editor – in secret.

2.3 Johan Reinert Reiersen: Veiviser for Norske Emigranter til de Forenede nordamerikanske Stater og Texas. Christiania: P.T. Malling, 1845.

3.

Dreaming of a Norwegian America 

“As the night fell, he saw a great castle shining in the distance”— the fairy tale of “Soria Moria”, the castle in a land far, far away, was recorded around the same time as emigration intensified. To Ole Bull, the world-famous Norwegian violinist, this “great castle” was America, where he believed a new and better Norway could be created. He founded the settlement of “New Norway”, popularly known as “Oleana” after himself, in Pennsylvania. 

Up close, the encounter with American realities proved harsh. Ole Bull’s settlement soon collapsed. However, the dreams of establishing a lasting Norwegian society and culture in America lived on. 

Norwegian immigrants wanted to come to America, but they did not want to become “Americans”. They were “Norwegians in America”, and they tried to demonstrate that they were the most American of them all. After all, it had been a Norseman, Leiv Eiriksson, who had discovered America, not Christopher Columbus. 

3.1 (Dummy kapitteloverskrift)

(Dummy gjennstandstekst)

(Dummy kreditteringstekst)

4.

The Profit of Longing 

Since the very start of the great migration to America, there was always someone seeking to profit from it. While emigrants were dreaming of a better life, ship owners, railway companies, government agencies, and other speculators dreamt of profiteering from those who were on their way to pursue happiness in the New World. 

Immigrants continued to be a source of profit. Along with a quickly emerging market for Norwegian-language books and newspapers, novel money-making opportunities were also spotted for those who knew how to play into migrants’ nostalgia and longing. Norwegian news became an attractive import good, and products which reminded the emigrants of the homeland became especially lucrative: postcards, photographs, stereography – the “3D” of the day – along with audio and video recordings helped sustain the longing to see and talk to friends and family once more, as well as to actually keep in touch across great distances. 

4.1 (Dummy kapitteloverskrift)

(Dummy gjennstandstekst)

(Dummy kreditteringstekst)

5.

Dreams That Sank

Since the very start of the great migration to America, there was always someone seeking to profit from it. While emigrants were dreaming of a better life, ship owners, railway companies, government agencies, and other speculators dreamt of profiteering from those who were on their way to pursue happiness in the New World. 

Immigrants continued to be a source of profit. Along with a quickly emerging market for Norwegian-language books and newspapers, novel money-making opportunities were also spotted for those who knew how to play into migrants’ nostalgia and longing. Norwegian news became an attractive import good, and products which reminded the emigrants of the homeland became especially lucrative: postcards, photographs, stereography – the “3D” of the day – along with audio and video recordings helped sustain the longing to see and talk to friends and family once more, as well as to actually keep in touch across great distances. 

5.1 (Dummy kapitteloverskrift)

(Dummy gjennstandstekst)

(Dummy kreditteringstekst)

6.

Dreaming of Gold

Since the very start of the great migration to America, there was always someone seeking to profit from it. While emigrants were dreaming of a better life, ship owners, railway companies, government agencies, and other speculators dreamt of profiteering from those who were on their way to pursue happiness in the New World. 

Immigrants continued to be a source of profit. Along with a quickly emerging market for Norwegian-language books and newspapers, novel money-making opportunities were also spotted for those who knew how to play into migrants’ nostalgia and longing. Norwegian news became an attractive import good, and products which reminded the emigrants of the homeland became especially lucrative: postcards, photographs, stereography – the “3D” of the day – along with audio and video recordings helped sustain the longing to see and talk to friends and family once more, as well as to actually keep in touch across great distances. 

6.1 (Dummy kapitteloverskrift)

(Dummy gjennstandstekst)

(Dummy kreditteringstekst)

7.

Boulevard of Broken Dreams? 

Since the very start of the great migration to America, there was always someone seeking to profit from it. While emigrants were dreaming of a better life, ship owners, railway companies, government agencies, and other speculators dreamt of profiteering from those who were on their way to pursue happiness in the New World. 

Immigrants continued to be a source of profit. Along with a quickly emerging market for Norwegian-language books and newspapers, novel money-making opportunities were also spotted for those who knew how to play into migrants’ nostalgia and longing. Norwegian news became an attractive import good, and products which reminded the emigrants of the homeland became especially lucrative: postcards, photographs, stereography – the “3D” of the day – along with audio and video recordings helped sustain the longing to see and talk to friends and family once more, as well as to actually keep in touch across great distances. 

7.1 (Dummy kapitteloverskrift)

(Dummy gjennstandstekst)

(Dummy kreditteringstekst)